On talk show Watch What Happens Live, host Andy Cohen plays a game called “Plead the Fifth,” where celebs are allowed to dodge only one of the three awkward questions he poses to them. Jennifer Lopez refused to say who’d she shag, marry and kill out of Ryan Seacrest, Keith Urban and Harry Connick Jr., but was down to give her opinion on her former fiancé Ben Affleck’s back tat.

“It’s awful,” says J.Lo. “I would tell him that, like, what are you doing? His tattoos always have too many colours. They shouldn’t be so colourful, they should be cooler.” See the rest of the video, including her comments on Mariah Carey, above.