Milo Ventimiglia has a controversial theory about who exactly might be the father of Rory Gilmore’s baby. (If you need us to explain why this is a matter of burning importance, this probably isn’t the article for you.)

Asked about who he thinks might have fathered Rory’s bombshell-in-the-bandstand-announced-child in the last ep of new revival, Milo offered up an intriguing idea: What if it wasn’t in fact any of the three people we all assume it had to be? ie. Maybe The Wookie, Logan and his character, Jess, aren’t the only possibilities?

“I don’t think it’s any of the three guys,” he said to Variety. “I don’t know. I haven’t really sat around and thought about it. I’ll be as surprised as anyone else is.” 

T-minus how long until we find out in the yet-to-be-announced next season?!