Poor Jimmy Kimmel. During an appearance on The Ellen DeGeneres Show this week, the talk show host was roped into a game of  “Who Would You Rather?” against Scott Eastwood.

And he didn’t stand a chance. “Are you smouldering?” Kimmel asked Eastwood, who used his washboard abs, blue eyes and best Blue Steel impression to hypnotize person after person. Watch the hilarious results – which include a four-person spooning situ – below.