We can forgive Jimmy Fallon for missing his first shot to get with Nicole Kidman but to mess that up a second time?!

Last night on The Tonight Show, Kidman recounted a – clearly traumatic –  story of how she was certain that Fallon (after failing to get her number at their first meeting/date) was going to ask for her digits at a mutual friend’s dinner party. (Sidenote: the mutual friend was director David Fincher.) But to her dismay, he was too distracted by — what else?— the buffet.



Hubby Keith Urban crashed the end of the interview, proving that even though she lost out with Jimmy, she still got her happy ending.

And in case you missed it, here’s Kidman explaining the first time she was snubbed by poor, oblivious Fallon.