Ricky Martin is engaged to his artist boyfriend Jwan Yosef, but he was so nervous to propose that he forgot the most important question.

“Instead of saying ‘Will you marry me?’, I said ‘I got you something!’” he told Ellen DeGeneres of the special moment. Yosef even had to remind him to pop the question.

But because love conquers all, Yosef forgave the blunder and accepted the proposal.